Our honesty pledge

HonestPlay exists for one reason: to give players a straight answer on whether a game, or a piece of gear, is worth their time and money.

What we promise

  1. We never sell reviews or scores. No developer, publisher or marketing agency can pay to post, remove, boost or bury a review. If anyone offers, we say no and we'll tell you about it.
  2. Ads are only ads. We show ads to keep the lights on. They are always labelled "Advertisement", kept separate from reviews, and advertisers get zero say over what's published. Nobody gets a better score because they bought ad space.
  3. Scores are a plain average. The number at the top of a game page is the average of every visible review, nothing more. We show the full spread of scores and the last 30 days so you can spot review bombing or hype.
  4. One person, one review. Each account can review a game or product once. You can edit it as your opinion changes, and edits are marked. Guests (no account) can post one review per game or product from their connection, and guest reviews are clearly labelled.
  5. Reviewers earn their rank. Members with a confirmed email can agree or disagree with any review. Once 3 or more members have voted on a review, it counts as agreed (60%+ agree) or disagreed (40% or less). Agreed reviews raise a reviewer's renown and disagreed ones lower it, moving them between ten ranks from Peasant to Dragonslayer. Ranks can go down as well as up, and nobody can vote on their own reviews. See the hiscores.
  6. Disclosure is required. If a reviewer got a free copy or sample, or has any connection to the people who made the game or product, they must tick a box and their review shows a disclosure badge.
  7. Negative reviews stay up. We don't remove reviews for being harsh. We only remove spam, abuse, unmarked spoilers, off-topic posts and undisclosed paid content.
  8. Moderation is public. Every review we remove and every account we suspend is listed in our transparency log, with the reason.

How we make money

Two ways, and neither one touches the reviews:

Affiliate links

Gear pages can have "Where to buy" links to online stores. Some of these are affiliate links: if you buy something after clicking one, the store pays us a small commission. It doesn't cost you anything extra.

Here's how we stop that money bending the reviews:

Spotted something off?

Use the "Report" link on any review.